Jenna Hartel
  • Welcome
  • News
  • Multimedia
    • INFIDEOS (My YouTube Channel)
  • Teaching
    • Teaching
    • Writings on Teaching
  • Advising
  • Research & Publications
    • Research & Publications
    • Google Scholar Profile
    • Interventions
    • iSQUARE Research Program Archive >
      • The iSquare Protocol
      • The Corpus
      • iSquare Studies
      • Outcomes
      • Pedagogical Applications

Message #4: Newsflash - Bates & Hjørland Debate

4/9/2011

39 Comments

 
Dear SIG-USErs,

I interrupt the previously scheduled message on “The Literature” of information behavior to draw attention to a debate unfolding in the broader realm of information science.  [For new readers: my posts to the SIG-USE mailing list are written with students of information behavior foremost in mind.] 

Recently Marcia J. Bates and Birger Hjørland have had an exchange in the pages of JASIS&T that continues a long-running public conversation between the two.  It is exciting to witness senior scholars championing their ideas, which serve as excellent fodder for students to discuss late into the night.

Below is an introduction to the situation and then remarks on a few implications for the information behavior research community. While I am an admirer and former student of Professors Bates and Hjørland, this statement does not take sides, has been approved by both participants as accurate, and cannot substitute for careful reading of the original papers (to that end references and hyperlinks are  provided).

Marcia J. Bates, professor emerita in the Department of Information Studies at the University of California, Los Angeles (USA), is the source of many breakthroughs in information science and information behavior specifically, in concepts such as information search tactics (1979) and berrypicking (1989); studies of the information behavior of humanists (1996); and as an editor and author of the Encyclopedia of Library and Information Sciences (Bates & Maack, 2010). In her work, she seeks to illuminate information behavior in ways that integrate the biological, behavioral, and social elements of human interaction with information in he world.

 Birger Hjørland, professor at the Royal School of Library and Information Science (Copenhagen, Denmark), is the architect of a socio-cognitive or domain analytic (Hjørland& Albrechtsen, 1995) perspective on information science. In this view information behavior is socially, culturally, and historically constructed (Hjørland, 2000). Hjørland’s writings of late (2011a, 2011b), as a series entitled “The Importance of Theories of Knowledge,” have sought to illuminate, critique, and strengthen the metatheoretical foundations of the field. 

The debate between Bates and Hjørland is philosophical and multi-faceted. It concerns the nature of information (as objective and/or social – see Bates, 2005, 2006 and Hjørland, 2007, 2009); the role of information science metatheories (as competing or complementary devices); and  the merits of two major metatheories (empirical behavioral research and socio-cognitivism/domain analysis). The most recent volley has explored these issues within the  concept of browsing (see Bates, 2007, in press; Hjørland, 2011b, in press).   

How is the public conversation between Bates and Hjørland relevant to the information behavior research community? 

Followers of this debate are reminded of the importance of metatheory in information research and are exposed to two metatheories that may be used to orient scholarship. (The metatheories, empirical behavioral research and socio-cognitivism/domain analysis, are both influential approaches within the information behavior specialty.) And, readers are shown possible conceptions of “information” as physical, biological, social, objective, or subjective. These various renderings can deepen philosophical understanding of our central phenomenon and/or be used to operationalize a definition of information within empirical information behavior research.  Further, these exchanges demonstrate how one concept – browsing – can be an epistemological and ontological hot spot, as can any information behavior notion. Finally, as observers of a public collision of minds we can refine our own communication and argumentation strategies.

Thanks to Professors Bates and Hjørland for these significant learning opportunities!

Other comments are welcome from members of the SIG-USE mailing list and beyond, especially remarks that engage these contested issues substantively (which was not the point here).

The next post, later in September, returns to the theme of “The Literature” of information behavior and features Donald Case’s textbook Looking for Information:  Survey of Research on Information Seeking, Needs, and Behavior, 2nd ed. 

Jenna Hartel


 References
[The reference list is in chronological (not alphabetical) order to better reflect the back-and-forth between the two authors]

 Bates, M. J. (1979). Information search tactics. Journal of the American Society for Information Science, 30, 205-214. 

Bates, M. J. (1989).  The Design of browsing and berrypicking techniques for the online search interface. Online Review, 13, 407-424.

Hjørland, B., and Albrechtsen, H. (1995). Toward a new horizon in information science: domain analysis.  Journal of the American Society for Information Science, 46(6), 400-425.

Bates, M. J. (1996).  The Getty end-user online searching project in the humanities: Report no. 6: Overview and conclusions. College & Research Libraries, 57, 514-523.

Hjørland, B. (2000). Information seeking behaviour: What should a general theory look like?. New Review of Information Behaviour Research,1, 19–33.

Bates, M. J. (2005). Information and knowledge: An Evolutionary
framework for information Science. Information Research, 10(4)
[available at http://InformationR.net/ir/10-4/paper239.html].

Bates, M. J. (2006). Fundamental forms of information. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 57(8), 1033-1045.

Bates, M. J. (2007). What is browsing – really? A model drawing from behavioural science research. Information Research, 12(4) [Available at http://InformationR.net/ir/12-4/paper330.html].

Hjørland, B. (2007). Information: Objective or subjective/situational?. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,58(10), 1448–1456.

Hjørland, B. (2009). The controversy over the concept of “information”: A rejoinder to Professor Bates. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 60(3), 643.

Bates, M. J. & Maack, M. N. (Eds.). (2010). Encyclopedia of library and information sciences, 3rd Ed. New York, NY: CRC Press.

Hjørland, B. (2011a). The importance of theories of knowledge: Indexing and information retrieval as an example. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 62(1), 72–77.

Hjørland, B. (2011b). The importance of theories of knowledge: Browsing as an example. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 62(3), 594-603.  
 
Bates, M. J. (in press). Birger Hjørland's Manichean misconstruction of Marcia Bates' work. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology. Currently available in early view online. 
  
Hjørland, B. (in press). Theoretical clarity is not “Manicheanism”: A reply to Marcia Bates. Journal of Information Science. Currently available in early view online. 

39 Comments
Trogir link
7/7/2013 08:24:24 pm

You have offered great information in your post and some things I have not seen in other content I have read by my friends

Reply
go to this site link
12/8/2013 11:50:55 pm

It was interesting to know more about you. It is great to know that you are a self-made woman. Your story is very inspiring. Thanks for sharing this with us and keep posting more updates regarding this in your blog.

Reply
write my essay link
26/8/2013 05:24:44 pm

The books being published today for children as well as the classics to get a feel for what's already been done and what's popular. Read literature for the age group for which you want to write. Thanks.

Reply
http://www.minkner.org link
14/10/2013 12:53:20 am

the debate was really interesting and I want to see more similar!

Reply
Buy Dissertation link
8/11/2013 08:58:44 am

This is my new i check out here. I discovered so many exciting things in your website especially its conversation. From the plenty of feedback on your content

Reply
Writing Services link
8/11/2013 08:59:03 am

Your blog looked so simple to design that I decided to create one, thanks!

Reply
psychology thesis link
12/11/2013 07:52:09 am

I admire the precious time and effort you put into it, especially into interesting articles you share here!

Reply
Mary link
15/4/2014 09:22:19 am

Excellent posts to read keep it up and keep going on this way. And keep sharing these types of things Thanks and I read your article and I keep reading your content.. It’s very interesting..

Reply
personal loans link
7/9/2014 07:57:49 pm

Loansdirect is initiated by group of experienced persons and started its operations in Chennai. The team was engaged in the financial services from the past 15 years and operated DSAs/DMAs for many banks. During the tenure, the team found gaps between prospective customer and bank services, which made to think further to provide qualitative & appropriate services to our valuable customer.

Reply
online chocolate shopping link
18/9/2014 02:11:18 am


We are leading Online Chocolate Shop in India to Orderdeliver Branded, Home made, Personalize, Chocolate Gift box ,
Satisfaction Assured and our comprehensive rage of chocolates are tailor-made to suite every palate, budget and occasion.

Reply
best bca project centers in chennai link
18/9/2014 02:15:18 am


1CRORE PROJECTS is one of the best project centers in Chennai,
1CRORE PROJECTS offers 2014 Final Year projects for Engineering students in JAVA, Dot Net, Android, Oracle, datamining,
embedded system and PHP technologies, 1CRORE PROJECTS is a one of the leading research and Development in Chennai

Reply
hp i5 laptop with 8 gb ram link
3/11/2020 06:24:53 am

Your thing with respect to making will be for all intents and purposes nothing hard to come by of amazing. This instructive article is unimaginably valuable and contains offered myself a superior answer for have the option to my own issues.

Reply
Shirley Andrews link
31/12/2020 03:40:19 pm

Thank yoou for being you

Reply
rajan tiwari link
17/3/2021 06:42:24 am

I’m not certain the place you are getting your info, however good topic. I must spend some time studying much more or working out more. Thank you for fantastic information I was looking for this info for my mission.

Reply
HMS Girl PG link
17/3/2021 06:45:18 am

You have made your points in a smart way. I am impressed with how interesting you have been able to present this content. Thanks for sharing nice information.

Reply
Nathuram link
17/3/2021 06:52:31 am

Really i appreciate the effort you made to share the knowledge.The topic here i found was really effective to the topic which i was researching for a long time.

Reply
Digital Training India link
17/3/2021 06:56:28 am

Enormous information in one blog post, I just love it. I must appreciate and mention that you completely know how to keep connected reader to blog post even if it is little long. Very good job.

Reply
Aluminium Profile link
17/3/2021 07:03:35 am

Thanks for sharing, please keep an update about this info. love to read it more. i like this site too much.

Reply
Aluminium angle link
17/3/2021 07:07:53 am

Really i appreciate the effort you made to share the knowledge.The topic here i found was really effective to the topic which i was researching for a long time.

Reply
padmawati Extrusion link
17/3/2021 07:15:03 am

You have made your points in a smart way. I am impressed with how interesting you have been able to present this content. Thanks for sharing nice information.

Reply
Digital marketing Modules link
2/4/2021 06:48:54 am

You are so creative! I really like this post. I hope to see much more from you in the future. I appreciate you and hopping for some more informative post

Reply
Nasha Mukti Kendra In Indore link
2/4/2021 07:03:06 am

I’m not certain the place you are getting your info, however good topic. I must spend some time studying much more or working out more. Thank you for fantastic information I was looking for this info for my mission.

Reply
Exo Terra Natural Glass Terrarium link
28/4/2021 03:59:33 am

I need to to thank you for this great read!! I absolutely loved every little bit of it. This was an incredibly wonderful post. Many thanks for supplying this info. I just would like to give you a huge thumbs up for your great information you have got here on this post.

Reply
Exo Terra Natural Glass Terrarium- large low link
28/4/2021 04:11:29 am

Excellent article. Keep writing such kind of information on your site. I'm really impressed by your site. I appreciate you for posting when you have the opportunity, Guess I'll just bookmark this blog.

Reply
exo terra swamp basking spot splash mist resistant basking spot lamp link
30/4/2021 10:31:20 am

The insights and the opinions shared in this blog are appreciable. Blogger seems like an educated and knowledgeable writer with sensible thoughts. Good work and Keep it up.

Reply
cbd oil for pets india link
14/10/2021 11:30:34 am

You need to take part in a contest for one of the finest websites on the web. I am going to recommend this blog!

Reply
Jim Corbett Safari Booking link
19/1/2022 07:42:34 am

Incredible points. Outstanding arguments. Keep up the amazing effort.|

Reply
Ranthambore Safari Online Booking link
19/1/2022 07:43:25 am

I want to to thank you for this fantastic read!! I certainly loved every bit of it. I have got you book marked to check out new things you post.

Reply
Gir Safari Booking link
19/1/2022 07:44:11 am

Hi there it's me, I am also visiting this web page regularly, this website is genuinely fastidious and the visitors are truly sharing fastidious thoughts.

Reply
Ranthambore National Park link
19/1/2022 07:44:56 am

Quality articles or reviews is the main to be a focus for the viewers to visit the website, that's what this website is providing.

Reply
jim corbett national park link
19/1/2022 07:46:43 am

Way cool! Some extremely valid points! I appreciate you penning this write-up and also the rest of the site is also very good.

Reply
gir national park link
19/1/2022 07:47:33 am

Great post! We will be linking to this great content on our site. Keep up the good writing.

Reply
best construction company in patna link
24/2/2022 02:20:31 am

Xpertscm is top leading construction company in Patna. Their latest ongoing several acres township project is Aquacity, which was design by international architects and those are really awesome.

Reply
Save Energy On Existing Hotel Infrastructure link
24/2/2022 01:08:13 pm

For most up to date news you need to visit web and on web I observed this site page as a best site for freshest updates.

Reply
Rishikesh Camping Shivpuri link
4/2/2024 06:36:18 am

thanks for wonderful post

Reply
Camping in Rishikesh link
4/2/2024 06:37:08 am

best post ever.

Reply
king11 link
30/5/2024 02:19:23 am

Xpertscm is top leading construction company in Patna. Their latest ongoing several acres township project

Reply
https://etherchain.io/ link
2/9/2024 08:08:43 am

For most up to date news you need to visit web and on web I observed this site page as a best site for freshest updates.

Reply
Marketing Via Digital link
24/3/2025 02:59:49 am

Turn to Marketing Via Digital – your go-to partner for clean, modern, and mobile-friendly websites. We create websites that not only impress visually but also rank well on search engines. Whether you're launching a startup, running a local business, or managing a growing brand, our team delivers web design solutions aligned with your unique goals. From crisp landing pages to robust eCommerce platforms, we bring your vision to life online. Build trust, attract customers, and grow your business with a professional website – right around the corner.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Jenna Hartel, Associate Professor, Faculty of Information, University of Toronto

    This blog contains postings to the mailing list of the ASIS&T Special Interest Group on Information Seeking and USE (SIG-USE). The postings began in August 2011 and are thematized; the first theme is "The Literature" of information behavior. While hopefully of interest to all devotees of information behavior, these postings are geared to  students.

    Picture

    Archives

    February 2012
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011


  • Welcome
  • News
  • Multimedia
    • INFIDEOS (My YouTube Channel)
  • Teaching
    • Teaching
    • Writings on Teaching
  • Advising
  • Research & Publications
    • Research & Publications
    • Google Scholar Profile
    • Interventions
    • iSQUARE Research Program Archive >
      • The iSquare Protocol
      • The Corpus
      • iSquare Studies
      • Outcomes
      • Pedagogical Applications