Jenna Hartel
  • Welcome
  • News
  • Multimedia
    • INFIDEOS (My YouTube Channel)
  • Teaching
    • Teaching
    • Writings on Teaching
  • Advising
  • Research & Publications
    • Research & Publications
    • Google Scholar Profile
    • Interventions
    • iSQUARE Research Program Archive >
      • The iSquare Protocol
      • The Corpus
      • iSquare Studies
      • Outcomes
      • Pedagogical Applications

Message #3 - The Literature: ARIST Reviews of Information Behavior

23/8/2011

9 Comments

 
Dear SIG-USErs, 

This post continues to address “The Literature” of our research area and celebrates a second major resource: the  Annual Review of Information Science and Technology (ARIST) literature reviews of information behavior. 

A special and important reference genre, the literature review is a survey of publications in a research area that summarizes major themes, developments, and findings. Literature reviews are time and effort saving devices for readers and the capstone of Shera and Egan’s “bibliographic pyramid” (1952) that underlies academic knowledge production. The authors of literature reviews are typically seasoned experts in a specialty or energetic younger scholars who use their dissertation literature review as a point of departure.  

I have fond memories of my early days as a doctoral student at UCLA and diving headlong into ARIST chapters, eager to “get my mind around”the information behavior literature. Each chapter proved to be a snapshot of information behavior scholarship in its day. As I moved longitudinally through the ARIST series, I was able to make out the contours, evolution, and personality of the information behavior domain.

In his textbook on information behavior, Donald Case (2006, 238-243) provides a great overview of ARIST chapters. He states that ARIST is “the main vehicle by which interested scholars kept abreast of research on information behavior” (p. 239). Still, he critically observes that the series is a real “patchwork” with“redundant” coverage and “underdetermination” of relevant documents (p. 241); further, he asserts that each review is not standardized but shaped by the predilections of the author. Case also notes that the early ARIST chapters (1966-1990) focus on “information behavior” as a whole and later iterations target narrower topics as the speciality matured and diversified. (For a handy listing of early ARIST chapters from Case’s textbook, click here.)

Certain ARIST chapters mark important advances inscholarship that devotees of information behavior should know. Paisely (1968)introduced the idea of information behavior within several nested socialcontexts; the same approach was rediscovered decades later and became a mantra and banner over the “information seeking in context” movement and conference (ISIC). A spirited chapter by Dervin & Nilan (1986) was a call to action to focus on the human information user (versus the information system) and is probably the most highly cited work in the information behavior literature. More recently,  Pettigrew, Fidel and Bruce’s (2001) contribution captures the increased methodological sophistication and diversity in our community. The latest comprehensive ARIST chapter on information behavior is a mammoth one by Fisher and Julien (2009), which invited the research community (via this mailing list) to nominate works for inclusion.

All SIG-USErs: Please share your thoughts on the information behavior chapters in ARIST. It would be especially interesting to hear from chapter authors:  Brenda? Paul? Karen? Heidi? Others?  

Thanks to Sarah and Lynn for stimulating responses to last week’s posting. Going forward, we consider another fine gateway into the literature: Donald Case’s (2006) information behavior textbook Looking for Information: A Survey of Research on Information Seeking, Needs, and Behavior 2nd ed.

Jenna Hartel

References

Shera, J. & Egan, M. (1952). Foundations of a theory of bibliography, Library Quarterly, 22, 125-137.




9 Comments
yacht charter link
8/7/2013 12:54:20 am

Thanks for the nice blog. It was very useful for me. Keep sharing such ideas in the future as well

Reply
go here link
11/8/2013 07:11:37 pm

I have great interest in books and literature. Literature review is a survey of publications in a research area that summarizes major themes, developments, and findings. Thanks for sharing this with us and keep posting more updates in your blog.

Reply
http://twitter.com/Yachtbookercom link
26/11/2013 06:48:27 pm

I would like to thank you for your nicely written post, its informative and your writing style encouraged me to read it till end

Reply
dissertation proofreading service link
26/8/2013 05:23:01 pm

The books are to read, writing them is a different story. A writer for children's literature puts just as much effort into his books as the writer who specializes in fiction for adults. Thanks.

Reply
here link
27/1/2014 02:35:20 am

This topic is the one that I have been looking into from last 3 days and your insight is extremely useful. Thanks for sharing this information

Reply
ABWE link
18/10/2013 07:20:04 pm

That is really wonderful reading, literature always shows the best and another way of thinking. I would love to get more literature stuff from you.

Reply
rfp writing link
11/11/2013 11:10:30 pm

Excellent! I admire all the helpful data you've shared in your articles. I'm looking forward for more helpful articles from you.

Reply
Isabelle link
15/4/2014 09:07:49 am

We’re a group of volunteers and opening a new scheme in our community. Your web site offered us with valuable info to work on. You’ve done a formidable job and our whole community will be grateful to you.

Reply
Fireplace Repair Alameda link
15/7/2022 06:36:30 am

Very thougghtful blog

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Jenna Hartel, Associate Professor, Faculty of Information, University of Toronto

    This blog contains postings to the mailing list of the ASIS&T Special Interest Group on Information Seeking and USE (SIG-USE). The postings began in August 2011 and are thematized; the first theme is "The Literature" of information behavior. While hopefully of interest to all devotees of information behavior, these postings are geared to  students.

    Picture

    Archives

    February 2012
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011


  • Welcome
  • News
  • Multimedia
    • INFIDEOS (My YouTube Channel)
  • Teaching
    • Teaching
    • Writings on Teaching
  • Advising
  • Research & Publications
    • Research & Publications
    • Google Scholar Profile
    • Interventions
    • iSQUARE Research Program Archive >
      • The iSquare Protocol
      • The Corpus
      • iSquare Studies
      • Outcomes
      • Pedagogical Applications